Challenges to Comprehension Implied by the Logo
of Laetus in Praesens
Laetus in Praesens Alternative view of segmented documents via Kairos

24th August 2003 | Draft

Future Challenge of Faith-based Governance


-- / --


Part A: Patterns of the Past -- Christian Complicity in Global Disorder
-- Faith-based governance, policies and programmes
-- Infallibility of Christian leadership
-- Democratic contradictions in faith-based politics
-- Resolution of policy dilemmas in faith-based politics
-- Faith-based evidence
-- Evil and demonization
-- Faith-based justice
-- Interfaith dialogue
-- Faith-based withdrawal of human rights
-- Torture under faith-based leadership
-- Faith-based military action: "Gott Mit Uns"
-- Faith-based intolerance of disagreement: avoidance of dialogue with dissenters
-- Transference of moral responsibility for deferred pain
-- Vengefulness and redemption
-- Complicity of Christian faiths

Part B: Towards Fruitful Patterns of Faith-based Governance
-- Addressing the fragmentation of the various faith communities
-- Historical review of failures of interfaith initiatives and their learnings for the future
-- Acknowledgement of faith-based errors of the past
-- Acknowledgement of the "shadow side" of any collective human enterprise
-- Challenge of any encounter with "the other"
-- Re-evaluation of Western and Christian criticism of other approaches to faith-based governance
-- Exploration of relevance of complexity studies to faith-based governance
-- Recovering a sense of complementarity necessary to understanding of complex truths
-- Constraining projections and the missionary impulse
-- Beyond exclusiveness and exclusion
-- Dissociation from the hegemonic agenda
-- Responding to the challenges of misrepresentation in faith-based governance
-- Reframing interfaith dialogue
-- Sustainable development and the relevance of faith-based preoccupation with virtues and vices



Western civilization emerged into the 20th century following the neutralization of the religious conflicts between Catholics and Protestants characteristic of previous centuries. A degree of separation of church and state was assured -- even in countries with state religions. This trend has been dramatically reversed through the uniquely Christian inspiration of the Coalition of the Willing under the leadership of the USA -- in what has been perceived as a "crusade" against the Islamic faith in particular and against dissidence in general.

The unique characteristic of organized religion in a complex world is a freedom from public doubt -- whatever private doubts may be matters of personal conscience. This degree of righteous conviction achieves its most emphatic and unconstrained expression in the leadership of the Coalition of the Willing. For it is indeed the case that George Bush (USA), Tony Blair (UK) and John Howard (Australia) are men of deep Christian faith, whether or not they are born-again Christians as in the case of Bush and Howard. Secondary members of the Coalition included the traditionally Catholic countries of Italy and Spain.

The world has had to struggle over centuries with the erroneous convictions of the Catholic Church regarding many insights of science -- as exemplified by the delay of four centuries with respect to the discoveries of Galileo [more]. These convictions were reinforced by an infallible papacy. This struggle now continues with the increasing conflict between creationism and evolution biology in the USA -- over which George Bush has claimed to be neutral -- and an emphasis on faith-based programmes both by Bush and Blair. A particular focus was provided in 2003 in the debate over the future European Constitution and the implications of including or excluding any mention of God [more | more].

The paper is in two parts. The concern here in Part A is to identify areas in which, through this righteous sense of knowing the truth beyond any reasonable challenge, Christianity is now directly complicit in aggravating world disorder -- in addition to the challenges presented by the many other problems of the world, including terrorism (see online Encyclopedia of World Problems and Human Potential). This is not to deny complicity of other faiths (notably Judaism and Islam) but that has been frequently analyzed in relation to the crisis in the Middle East.

The question is whether Christian leadership of the "free world" is now perverting the highest values of Christianity beyond recognition. There is however also a case for recognizing the degree to which science -- in contrasting its perspective with that of religion -- also constitutes a belief system that has some of the characteristics of other faith-based initiatives.

Such questions have some merit in a period in which the emergent American global strategy for the 21st century seeks to impose an American order worldwide -- an order based on American principles, and the privileged American relation to God, that many in other countries may be challenged to understand. Other members of the Coalition of the Willing believe, as articulated by Tony Blair, that it is futile to protest this hegemonic strategy and its benefits for the world. This hegemony is now being extended by the Bush Administration in the form of military control of what it terms "near space," thereby laying claim to the area of the Solar System that lies between the Earth and the Moon's orbit. "A key objective is not only to ensure U.S. ability to exploit space for military purposes, but also as required to deny an adversary's ability to do so," is how the Pentagon's Quadrennial Defense Review (2001) explained the strategy (see Joel Bleifuss. Rods from God. 2003)

However, if it is to be accepted, any such faith-based approach to global governance calls for a proactive exploration of the flaws apparent in previous faith-based approaches to governance -- on which historical perspective has been slow to emerge. Attention to the lessons of history is vital if world civilization is to avoid the traps of the past. Pointers in this direction are outlined in Part B.

Any reflection on faith-based "religious" approaches to governance, should also consider the nature of the "faith" placed by other sectors of society in their own preferred approaches to governance, including:

As remarked by John Ralston Saul:

Reason is a narrow system swollen into an ideology. With time and power it has become a dogma, devoid of direction and disguised as disinterested inquiry. Like most religions, reason presents itself as the solution to the problems it has created. (Voltaire's Bastards: the dictatorship of reason in the West, 1993).

Attention should also be given to the new degree of "faith" which the leadership in faith-based governance now expects the electorate to have in its judgement and capacity -- as with Tony Blair's appeals to "trust me" in a time of democratic deficit and voter apathy. There is considerable danger that "faith-based governance" will come to mean just that -- an unreasonable dependence on the part of those who govern in the electorate's "faith" in them, irrespective of strong indications suggestive of the need for a change of regime. This expectation is a characteristic of many non-democratic societies.

Part A: Patterns of the Past -- Christian Complicity in World Disorder

Part B: Towards Fruitful Patterns of Faith-based Governance


Azizah al-Hibri, Jean Elshtain, and Charles Haynes. Faith Matters: Religion and Public Life in America. W.W. Norton, 2001.

Babette E. Babich (Ed). Hermeneutic Philosophy of Science, Van Gogh's Eyes, and God Essays in Honor of Patrick A. Heelan, S.J. Fordham University, New York, and Georgetown University, Washington, DC, USA Book Series: Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science, Volume 225 [contents]

David Blankenhorn. What We are Fighting For. Institute for American Values, 2002 [text]

Stephen L. Carter. God's Name in Vain: The Wrongs and Rights of Religion in Politics. Basic Books, 2000.

Antonio de Nicolas. Neurobiology, Communities, Religion: A Bio-Cultural Study. 1998 (version in Experimental Gerontology Volume 33, Number 1/2, January-March 1998) [text]

Antonio de Nicolas. The Biocultural Paradigm: The Neural Connection Between Science and Mysticism. Experimental Gerontology, Volume 33, Nos.1/2,000-000, 1997 [text]

Antonio de Nicolas. Meditations through the Rg Veda. Shambhala, 1978

Maureen Farrell. "God Is With Us": Hitler's Rhetoric and the Lure of "Moral Values"., 7 December 2004 [text]

Peter Gabel. Spiritualizing Foreign Policy. Tikkun, May/June 2003 [text]

Stanley M. Hauerwas and Frank Lentricchia (Eds). Dissent from the Homeland: Essays After September 11. Duke University Press, 2003 (also South Atlantic Quarterly, special issue, Volume. 101, no. 2) [contents]

Michael Ortiz Hill. Mine Eyes Have Seen the Glory: Bush's Armageddon Obsession, Revisited. Counterpunch, 4 January 2003 [text]

Michael Ortiz Hill. Dreaming the End of the World: Apocalypse as a rite of passage. Spring, 1994

Geert Hofstede. Culture's Consequences: international differences in work-related values. London, Sage, 1984

John T. Jost, Arie W. Kruglanski, Jack Glaser, and Frank J. Sulloway. Political Conservatism as Motivated Social Cognition. Psychological Bulletin (American Psychological Association), 2003, Vol. 129, No. 3, 339-375 [text | review]

John T. Jost, Arie W. Kruglanski, Jack Glaser, and Frank J. Sulloway. Exceptions That Prove the Rule--Using a Theory of Motivated Social Cognition to Account for Ideological Incongruities and Political Anomalies: Reply to Greenberg and Jona (2003). Psychological Bulletin (American Psychological Association), 2003, Vol. 129, No. 3, 383-393. [text]

Anthony Judge:

Michael Kinsley. God Bless You And God Bless America. Slate Magazine, 25 January 2001. [text]

Bruce M. Knauft. 9/11 and the U.S. Production of Global Crisis (The Eighteenth Brumaire of George W. Bush: Paper for the Session "9/11 and Hegemonic Response: Global Emergency or Alarming Excuse?" of the annual meeting of the American Anthropological Association, New Orleans, 21 November 2002) [text]

Andrew Kohut, John C. Green, Scott Keeter, and Robert C. Toth. The Diminishing Divide: Religion's Changing Role in American Politics. The Brookings Institution, 2000. [contents]

Glenn Loury. 'God Talk' and Public Policy: a Considered Opinion. The Brookings Review, 17, 1999, 2 . [text]

Marc Luyckx. Religions Confronted with Science and Technology: churches and ethics after Prometheus. Brussels, Commission of the European Communities, FAST (Forecasting and Assessment in Science and Technology), 1992

Magoroh Maruyama. Mindscapes, social patterns and future development of scientific theory types. Cybernetica, 1980, 23, 1, pp. 5-25 [text]

E G McClain. The Myth of Invariance: the origins of the gods, mathematics and music from the Rg Veda to Plato. Shambhala, 1976

Mary Midgley. Myths We Live By. Routledge, 2003 [review]

Kinhide Mushakoji. Global Issues and Interparadigmatic Dialogue. Torino, Albert Meynier, 1988

Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life. Lift Every Voice: Report on Religion In American Public Life, 2002. [text]

Pontifical Council for Culture / Pontifical Council for Interreligious Dialogue. Jesus Christ: the Bearer of the Water of Life -- A Christian reflection on the "New Age". (Provisional report) 2003 [text]

Darrell A. Posey (Editor). Cultural and Spiritual Values of Biodiversity: a complementary contribution to Global Biodiversity Assessment, Intermediate Technology, 1999 (for the United Nations Environment Programme)

John Ralston Saul. Voltaire's Bastards: the dictatorship of reason in the West. New York, The Free Press, 1992 [review]

Richard Sennett. They mean well: the American flight from foreign politics into faith. Times Literary Supplement, 7 June 2002, pp. 6-8

Wayne Teasdale. Interreligious Dialogue Since Vatican II -- The Monastic Contemplative Dimension. Spirituality Today, Summer 1991, Vol.43 No. 2, pp. 119-133 [text]

Ronald F. Thiemann. Religion in Public Life: A Dilemma for Democracy. Washington, D.C., Georgetown University Press, 1996

Union of International Associations. Encyclopedia of World Problems and Human Potential. 1994-5

Sarah Voss. Zero: Reflections about Nothing by Sarah Voss. North Bend, Indiana: CrossCultural Publications, 1998

Sarah Voss. What Number Is God? Metaphors, Metaphysics, Metamathematics, and the Nature of Things. State University of New York Press, 1995

Jason Webster. Duende: A Journey in Search of Flamenco. Doubleday, 2002 [review]

Garry Wills. With God on His Side. New York Time, 30 March 2003 [text]

Garry Wills. Under God: Religion and America Politics. New York, Simon and Schuster, 1990

Martin Woollacott. Don't Blame Religion for the Killings Done in God's Name. Guardian, 11/29/2002 [text]

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

For further updates on this site, subscribe here