18 October 2001
International Organization Information / Research: 2001
-- / --
Prepared for Union of International Associations (General Assembly, 20 October 2001)
Report covering the period since the General Assembly, 23-24 October 1998
See also searchable PDF version (original titles, sub-headings, order and typography); also reports 1959-2006
Document also in segmented format in the Kairos indexed database
Organization profiles / networks
Yearbook of International Organizations: Regular editing and publishing of the following editions, currently complete with the exception of Volume 5:
- 35th (1998-1999)
- 36th (1999-2000): Vol 1 split into two parts, because of size
- 37th (2000-2001): Subtitle added: Guide to Global Civil Society Networks
- 38th (2001-2002): First edition published by Gale (USA) in the new format.
International Organization Bibliography and Resources (Volume 4, 6th edition).
Statistics,
Visualizations and Patterns (Volume 5, 450 pages): out in December 2001. This volume is a major effort to recover
and reconcile statistics from all past editions of the Yearbook (and statistical studies based on it
in Transnational Associations) and to present them with appropriate graphs and other
techniques. For this reason the UIA has allocated funds in excess of those provided by SAUR to
scan, format and correct the data. Of particular importance is the fact that since the 1950s the
statistical base has evolved with new categories of organizations requiring much effort to
reconcile apparent inconsistencies. In addition to graphically representing tabular data, the
publication will also include an extensive, and unique, range of images of networks of
organization, problems and strategies.
World problems / Strategic potential
Encyclopedia of World Problems and Human Potential: Work on the electronic version of
some databases in this publication continued under contract, as described below. No paper
version was foreseen, although tentative discussions continue.
Biographical profiles of leadership
Who's Who in International Organizations:
- 3rd edition, 1999-2000): Editorial work on the new edition was completed in 1999 and the publication was produced in December 1999. Portions of the revised text appeared in the subsequent versions of the Yearbook Plus CDROM (see below).
- 4th edition, 2002): A new edition is in preparation from mid-2001 for publication before the
end of 2002.
Meetings scheduled / Conference organization / Associate Membership
International Congress Calendar (quarterly): Work on this quarterly publication has continued in a
regular manner. It is now in its 42nd year. An online version is now operational (see below). The
statistics prepared from it annually, were presented for the first time with graphic and colour
enhancement in 2001. This was welcomed by the Associate Members for whom this publication
is exclusively prepared.
By-products / CD-ROM / Online
CD-ROM:
- Yearbook Plus: International Organizations and Biographies: The annual edition was
produced as planned in the normal manner in October of each year in 1998 through 2001 (7th
edition). It included part of the revised text from the Whos Who in International Organizations.
The issue of security against abuse of UIA CD's remains a matter of active concern – given the
ease with which CDs (and therefore the UIA CDs) can be copied.
- Encyclopedia Plus: Encyclopedia of World Problems and Human Potential: The production
of a CD version within the context of the contract through which some Encyclopedia databases
were currently being developed was excluded in preference to web publication. It remains a
possibility.
- International Congress Calendar: Although technically feasible, this is not envisaged for
commercial and security reasons.
Online: The main UIA website has been extensively revised and redesigned – although much work
remains to be done to unify the presentation and improve navigability.
In addition to the UIA's in-house network server, a distinction should be made between:
- Static page server: During the period since 1998, the UIA has maintained up to 11,000
static pages placed on the server of the non-UIA service provider (currently located in
Amsterdam). With some significant exceptions relating to current materials, these are
maintained on a relatively low priority basis. They generate a significant amount of feedback
and serve a major marketing function. A major shift was made during 1999 from access
offered to demo versions of the databases to dynamic access. Many static pages were
downgraded to point through to the dynamic pages – and more recently deleted. The period
July-October 1999 saw the relatively traumatic bankruptcy of the Agora service provider (a
cooperative of which the UIA was a founding member – thanks to UIA Member James
Wellesley-Wesley -- that was partly housed in the UIA offices) and a switch to the
commercial service provider that has itself since been absorbed into a multinational service
provider. Fortunately this did not affect the UIA site.
- Dynamic page server: The UIA also makes available information from its databases
dynamically on a UIA in-house server dedicated to that task and connected to the
Amsterdam service Most UIA databases are now "accessible" on the web. However the only
databases freely accessible to "Guests" are those relating to the Encyclopedia (namely the
Problems, Strategies, Human development and Values databases). The other databases are
only accessible minimally or for trial or for test purposes. However SAUR agreed in July
2000 to a system whereby the UIA makes available the Organizations database under
subscription that is integrated into the marketing of the book and CD versions. This was
started in September 2000 with the first paid subscriber from 26 September..
It is worth noting the understandable explosion in activity of international organizations on the Web.
Some 19,951 organizations now have websites. 21,762 have e-mail at their main offices, and 2,187
have e-mail at their regional offices. Of those having website, the evolution has been as follows:
- January 1996: ~300
- October 1997: 3,600+
- August 1998: 8,000+
- August 1999: ~12,000
- August 2000: ~16,000
- August 2001: ~20,000
Statistics on access to UIA websites are presented in Annex 1. The UIA dynamic site currently has
over 25,000 registered users
With respect to the online databases on the dynamic server (at https://www.uia.org/data.htm):
- Databases and access:
- Since September 2000, UIA databases for international organizations, world problems,
strategies, human development and human values have been online and interlinked –
extensive access is free of charge. Organization data is made available under subscription.
- The online version of the international meetings database is virtually completed and was
presented to Associate Members in October 2001
- Integration of UIA information is now at a historical point (after nearly a century of effort)
– with all its databases interlinked as a rich network of profiles.
- Users can now provide comments on specific profiles that are immediately integrated into
the database for access by other users.
- A new computer proof process has been developed to communicate more effectively with
all international organizations profiled in the Yearbook. A notable feature is that it gives
each organization a unique password enabling them to consult their own entry on the web
-- as well as that of any organization in their network that they cite as collaborators. For
the first time, it offers organizations a way of using the Yearbook free of charge without
undermining the contract with SAUR. Work has been started on the possibility of allowing
international organizations to update their profiles electronically.
- Access via visual displays (maps) continues to be enhanced (see below)
- Technical improvements:
- The databases have been successfully switched to a new server in the period November
2000-February 2001, because of demand and the weaknesses of the previous configuration. However because of weaknesses characteristic of any software package, this remains an area
of continuing major concern.
- Much effort has gone into increasing security features (notably against different forms of
abuse including excessive copying and virus attacks). This remains an area of major concern.
- Major software restructuring has been done to focus on user management and provide
specific and variable access rights for different categories of paying or non-paying users,
whether for marketing/trial purposes, to encourage organizations to supply/check
information, to limit possibilities of abuse, or to respect contractual relations with SAUR
- Associated facilities
- A secure on-line payment system has been developed and installed, with confirmation of
purchase arriving by e-mail. It is integrated with the UIA price-list and a currency
conversion facility. Adaptation to the euro has already been implemented. This reduces
workload and the use of paper and facilitates update of prices.
- Users can now sponsor editorial work on single entries or on whole databases through
online payments. This micro-sponsoring facility is an extension of the new online payment
facility and allows even small amounts (eg 1 euro)
- Users are now able to enable users to sponsor distribution of unsold copies of the Yearbook
that may otherwise be pulped
- Discussion fora have been created for users (at http://db.uia.org/forum/default.asp), and for
Associate Members, notably as a means of handling standard queries. It is indexed by search
engines.
- Significant progress has been made in relation to multimedia facilities (see below)
- Users can now obtain free automatic translations of UIA web pages from English into 8
languages (Chinese, French, German, Italian, Japanese, Korean, Spanish, and Portuguese).
This has been extended to the database profiles. Other possibilities are being considered.
User response from around the world to these facilities is satisfactory. UIA information services are
widely indexed by web search engines.
Associations review / journal
Transnational Associations: This is the subject of separate reports by Paul Ghils on editorial
issues, as well as by Joel Fischer on further electronic adaptation.
[NB: Versions of the UIA periodical: La Vie Internationale, 1912-21; Bulletin des associations internationals, 1943-44; Bulletin mensuel, 1951-53; International Associations, 1954-76; Transnational Associations, 1977-2001]
Research / Statistics
Documents: A number of documents were produced as the outcome of various projects:
- Information Context for Biodiversity Conservation: Final Report of EU info2000 contract
1997-2000, August 2000, 192 p
- INTERCEPT: Interactive Conceptual Environmental Planning Tool for Developing
Countries: Proposal for infoDEV activity, submitted to the World Bank (Industry and Energy
Department), 1998, 25 p (+ 150 pages of annexes)
- Reflections on UIA Strategy: collection of notes prepared by the Secretariat (and distributed
to UIA statutory meetings 1998-2000). May 2001
- International Meeting Statistics 2000 (prepared in colour for Associate Members)
NGO Security This specific theme has been developed by Allan Howard as a result of a Council decision as a
follow up to the Bettati survey and report on NGO on hazardous missions. This work will be
presented in a separate report. Essentially it has involved the following initiatives:
- research on the web
establishment of a discussion forum
- development of the UIA web site on this matter
- contacts with a number of parallel initiatives and concerned parties
- attendance at a briefing conference on the International Criminal Court as the most probable
locus for resolution of these matters
It should be noted that Allan Howard has made two presentations on related matters to meetings of
Associate Members
Other themes and papers: The UIA maintains a unique position in terms of documentary work and research on all
organizational forms. It has not become caught in the definitional traps and category game-playing
of "NGO", "third sector", "civil society", etc nor has its area of vision been restricted by
specialized areas of trade associations, pressure groups, etc
In this context it is appropriate to note the relevance of some of the research themes of recent UIA
papers. These include questions of:
- new approaches to dialogue
- comprehension across category and cultural boundaries
- strategic coherence under conditions of polarization
- implications for information systems and knowledge management
Research reports developed by UIA staff continue to be placed on the static web page facility.
Some
were prepared in response to events of the following:
- World Futures Studies Federation
- Nautilus Institute for Security and Sustainable Development
- World Affairs Council (San Francisco)
- First Global Brain Workshop: From Intelligent Networks to the Global Brain
- Foundation for the Future (Humanity 3000 Symposium)
- Millennium Leaders Summit for the International Meetings Industry
- US National Intelligence Council conference on "The Evolution of the Nation-State
through 2015"
- UNESCO-sponsored conference on "Knowledge and East-West Traditions"
The Info2000 media-focused contract has permitted significant breakthroughs in the visualization of
relationship information offers the possibility of new products. An Atlas of International
Relationships was discussed once again with SAUR – but effectively this is now incorporated into
the new Volume 5 of the Yearbook.
In response to a call for proposals by InfoDev (World Bank): Challenges and Opportunities of the
Networking Revolution (1990-2010), a study proposal in response to the call was prepared but
only submitted for information purposes to demonstrate relevance to the INTERCEPT project
awaiting funding. The study was subsequently developed and submitted as: Coherent Policymaking
beyond the Information Barrier (in response to an invitation from the Nautilus Institute for
Security and Sustainable Development in prepartion for a workshop in San Francisco, December
1999)
Under contract from the London School of Economics (through its Centre for Civil Society and
Centre for the Study of Global Governance), the UIA prepared an extensive set of statistical tables
that appeared in the new annual Global Civil Society report (2001).
In relation to the recent discovery by historians that Paul Otlet was one of the precursor thinkers
who envisaged in 1935 what is now the World Wide Web, a paper was prepared on:
Union of International Associations -- Virtual Organization: Paul Otlet's 100-year
Hypertext Conundrum ?
Many new research papers are now accessible on the UIA website (www.uia.org/uiadocs). Older papers,
notably from Transnational Associations, are progressively being scanned to make them accessible on
the web.
Articles in current issues of Transnational Associations are increasingly made available online.
Consideration is being given to scanning of UIA's historical (1910-1925) publications on civil society
to permit web access.
Academic network: Notably in relation to the bibliographical work on Yearbook Vol, Joel Fischer has maintained and
developed the (electronic) network of international relations scholars producing studies included therein.
This network also provides valuable leads for articles for publication in Transnational Associations
E. Multimedia
Developed initially under the Info2000 contract (1997-2000), as a means of increasing access to UIA
online information by a wider variety of users, visualization and sound techniques have now been
incorporated or are in process of development (see http://db.uia.org/scripts/sweb.dll/examples). Web
users have access to these facilities.
Smaller versions of maps have been printed on T-shirts, postcards and other products to give visibility
to the online facilities (https://www.uia.org/visuals). These were notably distributed on the occasion of
the UN World Conference on Social Development (Geneva, 2000)
Approximately 100 images created by this process will appear as pages in the new Yearbook Vol 5. (see
Annex 6)
16
The experiments with sound also offer interesting possibilities both from a cognitive perspective and
from a marketing perspective – permitting interaction with a new range of user.
Map posters: UIA has been able to solve some challenging technical problems of printing network maps generated
through its dynamic web site -- and is now able to produce high-quality, poster-sized (or larger), multicolour
maps of networks of problems, organizations or strategies for use in conferences. The UIA's
capacity to do this is unique at this time.
These experiments suggest the possibility of a significant new kind of product for the UIA from which
new revenue can be generated. They also have the possibility of being valuable, low-key, public
relations and marketing tools. One great advantage is that many different network maps can be
generated.
Knowledge management: A web summary of UIA's knowledge management work is available (at
www.uia.org/uiaprof/posie3.htm) This has been matched to the current EU research programs on the
information society (see Annex 5).
Archives A decision was made to reduce the UIA archive holdings of organizational descriptions that were
occupying much space, were of relatively low value, and necessitated unjustified staff time. Unlike
the previous culling, which was transferred to the Belgian Royal Archives some 10 years ago, on this
occasion the selected files were trashed.
Future development strategy / Proposals / Fund-raising
Strategic issues: The long-term strategic issues were discussed in a report to an earlier Council meeting (Reflections
on a Possible UIA Information Strategy). This forms part of a series of Secretariat notes since 1998,
summarized in a document of May 2001: Dimensions of Current UIA Strategy. A visual
presentation has also been prepared.
What follows is a checklist of issues for consideration:
- Positive features
- 1. Healthy financial position, with prudent reserves
- 2. Maintaining sales level (surprisingly good, according to SAUR) in a declining reference
market
- 3. Good relations with principal distributor (SAUR)
- 4. Solid core of dedicated personnel of proven capacity in producing complex information
products of a professional quality on a continuing basis under improbable conditions
- 5. Solid well-financed, contracted projects (with others in the pipeline)
- 6. Strategically well-positioned for the emerging knowledge society
- 7. Solid computer base: paid-up hardware base (workstations, etc); appropriate software; good
in-house expertise
- 8. Respected image amongst information users, web document readers, and participants at
conferences where UIA personnel make presentations (often by invitation)
- 9. Respected relationship to professionals in the highly competitive meeting industry (Associate
Members)
- 10. Substantial, appreciated, well-visited website -- strategically designed in relation to dynamic
page serving in test mode
- 11. Ready to roll on innovative interactive, participative relationship with user-suppliers of
information over the web
- 12. Good track record of de-centralized computer work (significantly positioned for any
transition to editorial teleworking)
- 13. Credible, cutting edge opportunities (consonant with EU Fifth Framework for Research and
Technology Development now shifting to "research which focuses on the social and
economic problems which face society today", and the like)
- 14. Operational implementation of innovative visual interfaces to respond the crises of meaning,
overview and information overload characteristic of the information society and the UIA's
information in particular
- 15. Core preoccupation with highlighting and enabling relationships (hyperlinks) between
initiatives crossing category boundaries, and the manner in which such patterns can be more
meaningfully comprehended, that is remarkably consistent with a 21st century interpretation
of what might otherwise be understood as a completely outdated name: Union of
International Associations.
- 16. Demonstrated continuing ability to sustain the above, despite the challenges identified below
- Challenging features
The UIA is in good shape. There are indeed challenging features to its current strategic opportunities. However a distinction should be made between:
- challenges to which a healthy organization should be expected to respond in a turbulent
environment;
- challenges which are cause for reflection on the appropriateness of the current response; and
- challenges which call for a serious revision in the current approach.
Making these distinctions is itself a challenge to which reference is made in the American adage: "If
it ain't broke, don't fix it.". Despite its current success, UIA Secretariat operations remain fragile and
vulnerable to inadvertent destabilization (as remarks on personnel indicate).
A particular concern is identifying which external parties should be considered as:
(a) competitors hostile to UIA aims and objectives
(b) competitors seeking to duplicate UIA core activities or deprive it of resources
(c) healthy competition where the UIA has adequate competitive advantage
(d) competitors taking on marginal UIA roles that the UIA might usefully consider
abandoning
(e) complementary initiatives to be welcomed by the UIA, but not duplicating any of its
programmes
(f) potential partners for new initiatives
- Evaluating future options Within the above context, with its various positive and negative dimensions, the question is how to
evaluate future proposals and projects. The response is strongly dependent on an understanding, or
reframing, of the complex of roles through which the UIA is defined.
Implicit in all these items is the challenge to the UIA of determining:
- (g) what constitutes effective action in terms of its mandate;
- (h) the nature of its future unique significant contribution, in the light of its mandate;
- (i) when to avoid feasible projects – for which other bodies are competent – when these
drain resources from strategically more significant UIA projects
- (j) when to avoid competing with other bodies that are more motivated to provide services
the UIA is able to supply;
- (k) what financial concessions it wishes to make, at what cost, to those it deems in need of
information services or other assistance;
- (l) what posture to adopt with respect to sponsorship arrangements which run the risk of
detracting from the UIA's image;
- (m)what effort to put into interacting with essentially indifferent IGOs operating short-term
strategies insensitive to duplication of effort and wastage of scarce resources;
- (n) how to make best use of personnel, or to pay for additional personnel, in the light of a new
pattern of requests.
- UIA title: As has been previously argued, it would seem that a prime clue to an appropriate response for the
21st century lies in a reinterpretation of the title of the "Union of International Associations".
The uniquely significant contribution of the UIA for the future might therefore be described in
terms of deriving coherence from patterns of transboundary associations. This focus is consistent
with its long-established documentation function -- but provides the vital context that is relevant to
the new need of many for coherence in a turbulent world. It distances the UIA from the tunnel
vision preoccupation of many well-resourced emerging information initiatives -- with which the
UIA would be foolish to compete. The art for the UIA is to strike a balance between provision of
coherence, for which there is little funding, and facilitating specialized uses of its information at
appropriate rates in order to sustain its activity.
- Conclusion: From a programmatic and resource-generating perspective, the UIA is in a highly successful period. This relies on a very competent and creative team of people who are highly motivated. However in these
turbulent and uncertain times, and given the many stresses to which international teams are subject, the
UIA program is vulnerable to destabilization. Some indications of this are already visible. The
consequences of the GALE takeover, combined with the wider consequences of 11th September, call for
caution.
Care needs to be taken to protect and consolidate what has already been achieved, works and offers
promise for the future. New projects should be undertaken as a natural development of these (enhancing
existing competences), rather than dissociated from them (requiring new competences).
Proposals:
- European Commission:
- Information Context for Biodiversity Conservation: Work on this DG-XIII contract (January
1998-December 1999) proceeded satisfactorily with respect to development of the Problems
and Strategies databases (see Annex 2 for further details). The contract was extended
through to 30 April 2000 to permit completion of certain tasks and to enable use of unspent
funds. Work on the web access facilities was satisfactorily. A special web access address
has been registered at www.ecolynx.org for this project. Work on the multi-media extensions
of this project is proceeding less rapidly, but the test interfaces already suggest dramatic new
approaches to access to UIA data (see demo).
Contract follow-up: In the period after completion of the EU 5th Framework project on
Biodiversity, and prior to the 6th Framework (now being released in October 2001), a visit to
a EU authority was arranged by Marc Luyckx to identify strategic opportunities for the UIA.
This produced the strong recommendation that UIA should partner with a "major company"
and should only focus on large budget proposals (in excess of 5 million euro) -- a major feat
for any nonprofit organization. Several initiatives were undertaken in conformity with this
6
recommendation: Bertelsman (competitor of SAUR), two Dutch companies, discussions
with a key IBM representative, a UK company, and with a Belgacom representative. However, in conformity with this recommendation, it is appropriate to recall the advantage
that UIA has in its relationship with SAUR (itself part of a "major company"). Possibilities
of submitting a joint proposal were discussed with the SAUR representative in July 2001.
- EU-India Economic Cross-Cultural Programme: A project under this programme has
been drafted together with Development Alternatives and offices of the Programme's offices
in Brussels and New Delhi. The call for proposals on this matter has been postponed by the
Commission.
- EU Fifth Framework Call for Proposals: This new call was put out by the European
Commission in March 1999:
A number of possibilities, complementary to the UIA's INFO2000, infoDev and IHEAL
initiatives, were considered for submission.
- FET Open Short Proposals (EU Future and Emerging Technologies section of the
Information Society Technologies programme of the EU Fifth Framework) : Cultivating
Knowledge Ecosystems, in collaboration with 1 NGO and 2 SMEs; submitted 15
September 1999. Amount requested : 100,000 euros. This was rejected in April 2000.
- Interactive Health Ecology Access Links (IHEAL) Project: The UIA was a sub-consultant
to the NGO UNED-UK, which had been funded by the European Commission (DG-XI) to
support work in preparation for the June 1999 Conference of European Environment and Health
Ministers. The UIA was responsible for the text content of a participative web database
(extension of the Encyclopedia) ; others were responsible for a GIS (mapping) component and
organization database. This was a pilot project solely to provide a demonstration at the Healthy
Planet Forum, the NGO event that ran parallel to the Conference of Ministers in June 1999. The
estimated total budget for the project is 63,888 EUR (£42,938), of which the 23,526 EUR was
allocated to the development of UIA databases. No further funds were obtained for further
development of the project.
- InfoDev (World Bank): Work on this project proposal to the World Bank was completed and
submitted under the title: Interactive Contextual Environmental Planning Tool (InterCEPT) for
developing countries. Amount requested: $250,000. After evaluation, the project was accepted
in June 1999 as a "highly ranked proposal awaiting funding" and so listed on on the Bank‘s
website. It was removed from the poll of such projects in March 2000 since no funds had been
made available.
- Rural Development Information: The UIA has continued its discussion with various groups
associated with rural and community development projects (in Scotland, Palestine, India and
Australia) concerning linkage (and distance learning) between a virtual community (Internet) and
"real" local communities, using the development of one to support the development of another. This would be a further extension of the INFO2000 / infoDev initiatives. Less emphasis was
given to these possibilities since June 1999.
- MyTown: During her last visit to Australia, Nadia McLaren initiated discussions with the
MyTown consortium based in Melbourne. MyTown is an online empowerment resource for
local community development. It is currently in pilot planning phase, under the support of major
7
corporate sponsors. Provisional access to the UIA databases is offered through the MyTown
website.
- TRACC: Tentative negotiations are underway to determine the feasibility of an Encyclopedia of
Transnational Criminal Organization. This is a project of the Transnational Crime and
Corruption Center (American University, Washington DC) introduced by UIA to SAUR, but
which may offer the possibilities for a partnership using materials from the UIA Encyclopedia.
- Congrex: The UIA has been approached by Congrex, a leading international conference
organizer, with a view to co-sponsoring an annual conference series in Paris (an "Association
Forum") for association executives (see Annex 3). Initially the first in the series was envisaged
for November 2002. However the organizational and financial implications, and unresolved
concerns about participation and objectives, as well as the number of meetings undertaken by
UIA currently (and their staffing implications) meant that further negotiations have been
postponed until after this General Assembly.
Future publishing developments
- CD and Paper publications Following with SAUR, it has been tentatively agreed to initiate a historical series of publications on
CD and/or paper. An initial evaluation prior to the GALE takeover resulted in a negative decision.
Subsequent discussions indicate that this can continue to be explored. In addition to an earlier
proposal for profiles of defunct organizations no longer published in the current Yearbook, these
might include scanned versions of the following early UIA publications:
- #2: Actes du congrès mondial des associations internationales. vol I: 830p, vol II: 415p
(1912)
- #3: Annuaire de la vie internationale. Tome I (1908) 1370p.
- #46: Actes du Congres mondial des associations internationales (1914) 1264p.
- #47: Annuaire de la vie Internationale 1910-1911 (1911) 2652 p.
- #104: Code des voeux internationaaux: codification generale des voeux et resolutions des
organismes internationaux (1923) 940p.
Possibilities of a future edition of the Encyclopedia of World Problems and Human Potential on CD
continue to be discussed with SAUR.
- Future publication on the World Wide Web:
The UIA is still in process of shifting from focus on the static server to a hybrid focus in which users
of the static pages are referred to databases accessible from the dynamic server. This involves:
- User authentication (password, etc) through which access to particular databases will be
restricted according to a wide range of marketing, partnership, sponsorship and editorial needs.
- Ability of a distant user to correct, supplement or criticize entries as a whole in any database, or
any field in that entry
- Ability to display back to the user all comments already received on an entry, by field (with the
possibility of e-mail contact with other users supplying comments)
- Ability to redisplay the entry with comments incorporated into the body of the description by
field to provide an overview of the amended entry
- Ability to qualify comments (eg "5-star", "3-star", "0-star") according to a system of
accreditation
- Ability for distant editors to edit particular entries.
Further work is required on this facility but it is currently being tested through open access to numerous users As indicated above, the subscription access to the Organizations database over the web is being extended to the Calendar database. These subscriptions will both be handled in a minimal ecommerce mode, namely by traditional invoicing for a password, rather than via credit card transactions. The contractual relationship with SAUR for the Calendar is likely to be handled differently from that for the Organizations.
For all databases, experiments will continue on the degree of access offered to "Guests" vs to various categories of users (at various rates).
- Other sources of web income envisaged from database use:
- Click-through revenue: Dynamic pages can be generated offering access to users to other web
sites by clicking through. Where the facility then accessed by user offers revenue for such
referral, the UIA can earn income from passing users on in this way. Typically this would be
appropriate in the case bibliographical information (amazon.com) or web search engines
(google.com). This is more appropriate when the facility does not require the use of special
logos. Experiments with this were briefly interesting but ceased dramatically as part of the
dot.com financial crash in 2000.
- Banner advertising: A small experiment has been conducted with the use of banner advertising
on a single static page. This is designed to generate income from advertisers when users access
the page on which the advertisement is running. The issue here is the obtrusive nature of the
banner and the relevance of the advertising. Banner advertising can be better and more
appropriately focused in the case of the Calendar database.
Publishing / Marketing
Contractual relationships with SAUR:
The UIA has had a mutually satisfactory relationship with its publisher K G Saur Verlag (Munich)
since the early 1980s (see Annex 4). Klaus Saur remains intimately engaged and recognized by the
international reference libraries (eg his relation to IFLA) and therefore continues to be a logical
partner. SAUR was acquired by Reed Elsevier some 10 years ago. In November 2000 it was sold to
Gale Research (Detroit), part of the Thomson Group. Gale has long been the publisher of a principal
competitor of the UIA Yearbook of International Organizations in the USA, namely the
Encyclopedia of Associations. However, such is the relationship between competing bodies in this
market, there have been occasions in the past when Gale was distributing UIA publications for
SAUR.
This major change gave rise to much discussion between SAUR and GALE and SAUR and UIA
regarding the intentions of GALE and the probable treatment of the Yearbook as marketed with the
GALE Encyclopedia. The following points should be noted:
- GALE is a major marketer of reference books, and therefore technically this is excellent for
improved sales of the Yearbook, especially in the USA
- SAUR has been acquired by GALE as an independent publishing house because of its
performance. All parties recognize that it would be foolish for GALE to intervene
unnecessarily – at least in the short term.
- SAUR is extremely keen to continue to benefit from the collaboration with the UIA and has
been very attentive to UIA concerns, some of which they share
- Contracts are negotiated between UIA and SAUR, not with GALE
- GALE has sought economies of scale by printing and binding in the USA, necessitating a
change in format from A4. This is the case with the current edition of the Yearbook. This
poses new shipping problems.
- GALE produces and markets only a relatively limited range of CD-ROMs to any degree but
does have a very strong online service
- GALE has sought to purchase data from the Yearbook as part of a "collaborative
relationship". The UIA has refused. GALE notably has an editorial policy of buying data
from any convenient source and selling it on to any buyers. The UIA refusal caused some
stress.
- As part of improving the relationship, SAUR has made proposals for other publications,
notably a new hardcover edition of the UIA Encyclopedia of World Problems and Human
Potential.
Given the events of 11th September 2001, it is of course absolutely unclear what will be the effects
on the global economy, on the US economy, on library budgets, and on purchase of European books
by American libraries (a "loyalty factor"). Consequently it remains unclear what will be the situation
for the UIA. According to a preliminary economic assessment issued in October 2001 by the World
Bank, the terrorist attacks in the USA will negatively affect the already dim forecast of global
economic growth for the next two years, and will severely impact upon the growth of developing
countries worldwide.
Sales and marketing through SAUR/GALE:
Reported sales levels have been maintained in a difficult market, possibly due to the web marketing
effectively undertaken through the UIA static and dynamic pages on the web. SAUR is clearly
impressed at the staying power of the Yearbook in particular, and of UIA publications in general.
As indicated above, these are exceptionally uncertain times and how sales will be affected by the
combination of the foreseen recession and the GALE marketing strategy are a matter of concern for
the coming period.
Internet marketing through UIA:
The UIA staff has built up considerable in-house familiarity with internet marketing skills. These
have yet to be applied systematically because of the need to implement facilities to make the online
system as user friendly as possible and to handle a variety of users with different financial
arrangements. Internet marketing represents a considerable advantage over conventional paper-based
marketing in terms of cost and distribution – especially for markets thinly distributed worldwide.
A significant issue relating to marketing, given the size, complexity and scope of the UIA web site,
has been the allocation of resources to its management, notably from a design and navigability
perspective, especially the integration of the static and dynamic sites. Some resources have been
allocated to this but much remains to be done.
The work on non-text media (see below) is expected to prove a fruitful form of interaction with a
wider audience.
A discussion paper on the issues facing UIA was prepared by William Martin, a Scottish colleague
with experience in this area, following his visit to the UIA. and presented to a recent Council
meeting.
In response to the many opportunities of the web, the UIA has developed (partially in response to the
subscriber needs suggested by SAUR) a range of user categories:
- Non-paying users:
o guest/trial user
o registered user
o international organizations
- Paying users:
o name/password user
o IP user
o IP range user (for large institutions)
Of the 63 paying subscribers to Yearbook Online, 20 are UN institutions (clients negotiated by
SAUR, not within the framework of consultative status relations), with remainder being universities,
research institutes, convention bureaux and other bodies.
Users of both the UIA's static and dynamic web facility are located in every country of the world
ensuring significant visibility of the UIA in ways that were not previously possible.
Web "launch": The UIA has committed to "launching" its website in one form or another. To date this has been
done through various gradualist techniques. UIA web exposure is good considering the low level
launch activities, with links to our site and resources from a wide range of constituencies –
whether on the initiative of the responsible web managers or through prompting by Joel Fischer.
However much of the organization data on the web quickly becomes stale, either due to loss of
funding or lack of initiative. Thus UIA does need to "promote" / launch when it is ready to do so in
order to make its authoritative presence known and felt in the internet environment. "Start up's" in
this area are able to garner attention / success because they promote widely and loudly.
Unsold copies: The pulping by SAUR of the unsold copies of the regular publications continues to be a source of
regret. Two initiatives have been undertaken in this respect:
- A UIA staff member, Tömás J Fülöpp, undertook to transport 20 copies from the SAUR depot in
Germany to Slovakia for distribution to NGO networks there and to bring back an equivalent
number from the German depot to the UIA Secretariat for distribution from there
- As noted earlier, a facility has been made available on the UIA web site to enable users to
sponsor distribution of unsold copies
Statutory meetings / Membership
Technical facilities now exist within the UIA to enable a variety of formats of electronic meeting of
UIA Full Members. They include:
- simple e-mail
- listservers (or via Pegasus)
- discussion fora
- "chat" facilities
- video conferencing
The principal factors inhibiting such development in practice are:
- equipment and software conveniently accessible to Members
- willingness and aptitude of Members to make use of such facilities
- any need to coordinate times for simultaneous interaction as opposed to asynchronous
interaction
- personnel resources to manage such interaction from the Secretariat
- any moderation required to maintain the focus of such interaction
- tendency of such dialogue to fail to meet the expectations of some and to be
disproportionately over-used by others
Secretariat / Administration / Human resources
Office-related issues:
- Security and fire risk The physical (as opposed to electronic) security of the UIA offices remains a matter of concern due
to the way the offices are used by people working a variety of hours, in a building of offices in which
there are people working a variety of hours, and in which there are public meetings outside office
hours -- and there is no permanent concierge service.
On 26th December 2000, a fire was detected by chance in a UIA front office at 6.30 in the morning. Fortunately the damage was slight, but the office was only finally reusable after repairs by the state
landlord, mid-October 2001. In the light of current threats of bio-terrorism, the potential threat to UIA via incoming mail should
be recognized.
-
Use of offices Due to uncertainties associated with the future of the MAI, it is not clear how UIA should plan to
make best use of its office space and the computer cabling in which it has invested.
The 9-month delay in refurbishing one office is an indication of a dysfunctional situation. Another is
the peremptory requirement that a series of offices be vacated to permit widow frames to be
upgraded – nullifying the UIA investment in necessary window blinds, and requiring investment in
a new set.
-
Furniture The UIA was fortunate to receive three major donations of quality furniture during the reporting
period. Two of these were from a multinational corporation.
Working methods:
Work on publications is increasingly undertaken with much greater reliance on:
- work away from the Brussels secretariat: the logo project was largely undertaken from
Leuven (home of a former UIA staff member, who has since again become a staff member),
as was the recent Who's Who project, contributions to the Encyclopedia databases, and
Yearbook commentary materials; major editing of the Yearbook is now done very
successfully in London; development and production of the CD-ROM, previously done in
Montreal, has been switched to Paris, and now to London and Amsterdam with little
disruption (following the movements of the person responsible).
- electronic mail and file transfer: with editors working at a distance, the UIA has
effectively been experimenting with a form of "tele-working"; international organizations
increasingly communicate with the UIA by e-mail, notably concerning the Yearbook; much
information is obtained from the Web. It is planned to further experiment with this mode of
operating in the light of new developments with dynamic web publishing on its server.
- flexible working arrangements: volunteers made some contributions to the Encyclopedia
(and hopefully will continue to do so in the future) and to the preparatory work for the French
translation of the Yearbook; stagiaires have been used for translation work. In some cases
this has been converted into paid work, even in the form of contracts.
These developments are partly in response to budgetary constraints, to the needs of individuals, or
to the desire to benefit, or continue to benefit, from known expertise with UIA data and programs. It
is expected that the UIA involvement with the Web will further change the balance and nature of
secretariat operations.
In response to the electronic environment, UIA staff continues to achieve unusual breakthroughs
using in-house tools and resources; support and purchase of such resources are undertaken frugally.
Much useful software can be obtained freely from the web. The electronic environment is causing
rapid changes in the: internal modes of work; the way information flows to and from the UIA; as
well as between personnel.
Personnel
salaries remain a regular concern of staff; due both to the Belgian system in general and the high
rate of tax. Staff are now acquiring skill sets (e.g. broader computing and internet specific) which
would make them extremely attractive in the commercial sector. Additionally, non-Belgian staff are
at a distinct disadvantage when it comes to residency, taxation and social security (pension) issues.
UIA continues to face challenges of identifying qualified candidates for open positions, in the light
of the above constraints. Additionally, while more continues to be achieved with less, there are
19
concerns about what elements might be lost as the Yearbook operation adjusts to a smaller staff, a
larger share of information available through the internet, and increased electronic contact with
organizations. The under-staffing situation tends to be severely aggravated by long-term illnesses of
key personnel.
Under-staffing: Although considered to be characteristic of many nonprofit bodies, it is useful to
recognize its nature in the case of the UIA:
- It is vital to recognize that the UIA generates its resources almost entirely from the activities
of the limited number of Secretariat personnel whose capacities are already severely
stretched.
- Unfortunate compromises have to be made with regard to delaying or neglecting certain
obligations, notably courtesy responses; this is especially unsatisfactory when they might
develop into further income-generating work
- The possibility for taking on extra tasks is very limited unless the tasks are an extension or
development of existing program tasks and skills
- Extraordinary tasks have the potential to be extremely destabilizing of existing program
commitments, especially in relation to regular production deadlines
- Locating and taking on extra staff, usually involves delays before the new person is proven to
be useful in complex tasks; the person necessarily requires training that is itself a drain on
existing personnel working on urgent tasks.
- Recommendations to engage in remedial fund-raising of any kind should therefore bear in
mind the (often "unprofitable") investment that this normally requires in Secretariat time
and/or advising external parties (for example the 18 month cycle in the case of the
"successful" proposal to the World Bank).
Any assistance of Full Members in directly obtaining additional funds (as exemplified by the actions
of James Wellesley-Wesley over the years), rather than recommending that the Secretariat take
initiatives to obtain such funds, would therefore be much welcomed.
Computer-related infrastructure
In-house (database management, publication production, accounting, mailing):
The extensive UIA computer system continues to give satisfactory service. Although there have been
some serious system failures, these have not been unusual for such a system and downtime has been
very limited -- thanks above all to the in-house maintenance skills of Joel Fischer as de facto system
administrator. Vigilance is however required with regard to security-related issues and back-ups. It is
important to recall the degree to which UIA database maintenance, publication production,
accounting, marketing, mailings, e-mail, and web research are dependent on this system:
- Workstation hardware naturally continues to require replacement or upgrading, notably to
provide web and e-mail access from workstations, and significantly in order to enable further
development of web and multimedia facilities. This upgrading process was also a response to
problems potentially associated with the Y2K issue (only minor problems resulted at the
time). A sophisticated workstation was donated (as a long-term loan) to UIA by HP-Belgium
following solicitation to several computer manufacturers
- Workstation software also continues to require upgrading, notably in response to the
increasing threats of virus attacks and to more challenging applications (statistics, graphics).
The possibility of making partial use of Linux-based systems has been successfully tested,
and continues to be reviewed. A Linux server will be installed operationally to redistribute
work currently handled by the UIA's dynamic server. The accounting package is being
upgraded to handle the euro conversion.
- Network hardware and software: Although this has given satisfactory service, the version
currently in use is several generations out of date and is no longer maintained by the
suppliers. A major in-house review is therefore in progress to determine how to upgrade
both software and hardware components in the immediate future.
- Proofing: Dispatch of e-mail proofs to organizations has been successfully undertaken in
large quantities. This significantly reduces postal and handling costs and appears in some
cases to generate a better response rate. It also ensures more direct and continuing contact
with organizations. (see also remarks on online proofing)
Dynamic server (user access to online databases): The independent server facility has been developed since 1999 and is now reasonably satisfactory,
thanks especially to Tomás Fülöpp. The server has been the subject of continuing concern because of
technical uncertainties (common to such development), the quality of the hardware and software, the
frequent need for upgrades (often freely available on the web) as problems are discovered, back-ups
in case of major failure, virus attacks, etc.
The first server has twice been replaced in terms of hardware, and once in terms of database
software, in order to improve the quality of service.
The UIA is very fortunate in that the format of the data on its in-house server is identical with that
for its dynamic server. However there are continuing concerns about how to maintain
communication between the two systems (to ensure users have access to updated information)
without increasing the risk of virus and attacks to which such systems are vulnerable on a daily basis.
Now that it may be queried 24 hours a day, 7 days a week – and through holidays – any failure in
services has serious consequences for users and for the UIA. Unexplained failures have proved to be
especially challenging.
External / Static server (unchanging pages)
This facility has proved remarkably successful with an average of approximately 200,000 hits per
day.
The UIA web and e-mail facilities survived the bankruptcy (in July-September 1999) of the Agora
cooperative (of which the UIA was a founding member). The facility was taken over by XS4ALL (in
turn taken over by KPN), and transferred to computers in Amsterdam -- all in a four month period.
Whilst service has been maintained throughout (not without moments of anxiety), there have been
problematic technical and commercial issues (some to the UIA's advantage).
In September 2001 the shared 126k leased line from the Secretariat to this service provider was
significantly upgraded to 256k UIA-reserved line for the following reasons:
- to improve access from the web to the databases on the UIA's dynamic server, notably for
subscribers and international organizations checking their profiles
- to improve access of UIA personnel to the web, notably for organization research
- to open the possibility of relocating the UIA's static page server from Amsterdam in order to
cut costs
Distance editing:
The possibility of enabling people to update database entries from a distance, and even to maintain
the system in some instances, continues to be a developmental challenge. Already the UIA has two
editors operating at a distance; some system maintenance is also done from a distance. Improved
facilities are envisaged to increase the options offered by this approach and to reduce the time wasted
in reconciling work done at a distance with that done in-house. These technical developments open
up possibilities with respect to a more flexible involvement of UIA staff and collaborators to bypass
some of the difficulties associated with requiring the presence of personnel in Brussels.
Again an important feature of this challenge is that of security – but also of managing a network of
knowledge workers who do not meet face-to-face (or only rarely).
[See Annexes in PDF format]
Annex 1 Statistics on access to UIA websites
Annex 2 Info2000 project
Annex 3 Association Forum (Congrex)
Annex 4 Historical review of UIA collaboration with SAUR
Annex 5 UIA Strategic Match with IST Fifth Framework Programme
Annex 6 Selected images from Yearbook Vol 5
2